Notes from the community meeting held on Wednesday 6th June 2018
Members and non-members were invited to the meeting to share their ideas with the LCT directors. Invitations had been sent to all members by either email or post and posters had been placed up at Garve Hall and Achnasheen in order that non-members were also aware of the meeting. Information was also placed on the LCT website.
SW welcomed everyone and delivered a report of the projects that had been approved since the last meeting as detailed below.
Present: 8 LCT members
LCT Board: Sharon Wright, Jean Bailey, Jeanette Fenwick, Karen Grant, David Raeburn, Chris Hamilton, Carol Smith (LCT Company Secretary)
Non Members: Tina Hartley, Lucy Beattie
Apologies: John Bedwell (LCT Board)
Approved grants
The following grants have been awarded since the last community meeting:
| Applicant | Project | Project Cost | Grant Requested | Grant Approved |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ullapool High School | Japan Trip Educational trip to Japan undertaken by 41 participants |
£77,589 | £3,000 | £500 |
| The Garve & District Development Company | Children’s Holiday Activities Taster Days To provide a range of children’s holiday activities in local area |
£1,995 | £1,995 | £1,995 |
| Strathpeffer Primary School Parent Council | Playground equipment To provide a playground slide and scramble net in the school playground |
£11,995 | £3,000 | £3,000 |
| Highland Museum of Childhood Trust | Station Building redecoration Repainting of station building |
£3,650 | £2,375 | £500 |
| Strathpeffer Under 5s | Learning Resources Purchase of new learning resources to improve active learning |
£950 | £950 | £950 |
| Garve & District Community Council | Community ceilidh To hold a ceilidh open to all within the community |
£775 | £775 | £775 |
| Mossford PWS Group | Legal costs of borehole To support the legal costs of creating a borehole following contamination by SSE of existing water supply |
£5,130 | £5,130 | £5,130 |
| Strathpeffer Medical Practice | Defibrillators Defibrillators for Dingwall Branch surgery |
£1,550 | £1,000 | £500 |
| The Garve & District Development Company | Community Hub website The development of a Garve & District website to be used by all groups and members of the community |
£5,000 | £5,000 | £5,000 |
| Strathpeffer & District Community Rowing Club | Skiff project To build and then enable members to row a St Ayles Skiff |
£6,050 | £1,393 | £500 |
Rejected grants
| Applicant | Project | Project Cost | Grant Requested | Grant Approved |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dundonnell Mountain Rescue Team | Pocket Defibrillators Purchase of 3 pocket defibrillators and service and software upgrade on existing 2 pocket defibrillators |
£6,090 | £6,090 | £0 |
Financial summary
Grants paid
In the current financial year, LCT expects to authorise grants totalling about £265,000. In the year to 31 March 2018 grants totalled £318,974, compared with £24,487 in the previous year.
LCT income for grants
Eneco is expected to pay £189,000 in September 2018. There is still no news or confirmation about the contribution expected from EDF for the Corriemoillie windfarm. Due to the delay there will be 2 years of funding once it is received. JB updated the meeting with information from the GDCC meeting. It is understood that there is a further group within EDF-ER that wish to also look over the legal agreement and this is causing the delay. This was further confirmed by Ed Tarr.
Support to community groups
LCT has met and offered support to the following groups as part of the application process:
- The Garve & District Development Company
- Garve & District Broadband
Questions and comments from the community
- How do you look at who gets a grant award?
-
SW explained that the Board uses the scoring matrix that has been previously shared with members. The projects may either be within the Garve & District CC area or of benefit to the area though not actually within it. For example the Strathpeffer Under 5s playgroup has been awarded funds as there are no playgroup facilities within the area and as the nearest it is attended by children from the area. Strathpeffer school was awarded funds as there are children from the area who attend the school (note – SW did not participate in the discussion or the vote on this award due to a conflict of interest). A small grant was provided to the Strathpeffer Museum of Childhood as it is utilised by members of the area. The Wyvis Distillery in Dingwall was not awarded funds as there was no benefit to the area or its residents.
- Is there a set % of the community that has to benefit to receive an award?
-
SW explained that there is no set % of the community that has to benefit to receive an award. However if the award is outwith the community information is requested from the applicant as to how many people from the GDCC area will benefit.
As part of the scoring criteria the results of the Community Benefit Survey are considered and the greater the priority on the survey the higher the score that the project is awarded.
It was agreed that LCT has taken great strides forward in communicating with the community. The Garve & District Development Company offered that once its online community hub is available LCT will utilise this.
- Is there consideration of the available funds when the Board reviews an application?
-
The Board considers the application on its individual merits and does not review the available funds. With the establishment of the Garve & District Development Company it is hoped that there will be more large scale applications. Should this be the case and there was not sufficient funds available LCT has the ability to borrow funds. CS explained that there should be further funds becoming available from EDF-ER at some point.
- Why did LCT pay awards to applicants outwith the area and of no direct benefit?
-
A small grant of £500 has been awarded to Ullapool High School as a gesture of goodwill. This was awarded following discussion by the Board and a partial grant was awarded. There was a view that if it is of benefit to the Highlands then it will have a benefit to Garve.
During the Foundation Scotland audit conducted last year the recommendation was that LCT should set aside 20% of its funds for projects outwith and of no direct benefit to the community but this was rejected by the Board.
There was a general feeling from members that grants should not be paid as goodwill gestures to organisations or initiatives that are outside the area and/or are of no benefit to the area.
Tina Hartley (Community Engagement and Development Officer – Garve and District Development Company) recommended not paying goodwill payments
POST MEETING NOTE – The grants awarded by the current Board are as below:
GDCC area and of direct benefit – 97% Outwith but of some benefit – 2% Outwith and of no benefit – 0.11%
- Would the Board consider taking 10 projects suggested by members that are outside of and of no direct benefit to the community and only take forward 2 projects voted on by members
-
The Board will review this suggestion at its next Board meeting
- Should LCT seek comments from members prior to grant awards
-
CS explained that a summary of grant awards is sent out via email and post to members and is also put on the LCT website and Facebook page. Comments are requested but generally there is little response.
It was suggested by Ed Tarr of the Garve & District Development Company that the online community hub could be used to provide access for members to provide their comments. It would also be possible to put a voting button but it was suggested that the voting button would not be advisable. LCT would welcome comments via the community hub.
- If challenged on smaller projects could you share the scores with the community
-
Following the audit last year by Foundation Scotland the recommendation from them was to not share the scores as it becomes a black and white answer and does not lead to discussion.
- Can you put contingency into a grant funding application
-
Yes and this would be expected with large scale projects. The Garve & District Broadband group application had contingency within it and was fully funded
- At what stage is the Development Company?
-
Ed Tarr (as the Chair of the Garve & District Development Company) explained that the members of the Development Company should be getting an update. One member explained that she does not have email and requires the information to be sent out by post, as LCT does. Tina Hartley explained that they were compiling this information and would be posting out where appropriate.
Tina also explained that an application has been sent to LCT for a digi-hub which will provide broadband to Garve hall and also resources and training for those that require it to enable all within the community to be Internet and email capable.
Lucy Beattie asked whether there was a need for activities for young people within the community as she is looking to establish 3 activities. KG suggested that the activities suggested would probably be more attended by Primary children but a Youth Club for older children would be good.
Ed Tarr explained that the Development Company is looking at arranging social events and trips outwith the area as they wish to tackle loneliness within the community. CS explained that in Strathnairn such events are organised including a Friendship group and a Seniors lunch club which utilises the community minibus.
- Has LCT received the income from Ledgowan Hydro?
-
CS will check when this money will be received