Notes from the community meeting held on 13th June 2017
Members and non-members were invited to the meeting to share their comments and suggestions on LCT. SW welcomed all of the attendees and provided the update of activities since the last meeting as follows.
Present: 7 LCT members
LCT Board: Sharon Wright, Jean Bailey, John Bedwell, Jeanette Fenwick, Karen Grant, David Raeburn, Carol Smith (LCT Company Secretary)
Approved grants
Update since last meeting on 6 February 2017. The following grants have been awarded in the last year.
| Applicant | Project | Grant Requested | Grant Approved |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Garve & District Development Company | Rebate Scheme * This is open to all households in the GDCC area and is £250 per household towards energy costs |
£44,650 | £44,650 |
| The Garve & District Development Company | Household Energy * This is open to all households towards the cost of energy efficiency measures within the home |
£7,400 | £7,400 |
| The Garve & District Development Company | New Local Energy * To review the options. However if these schemes are not Assessment viable LCT will not fund further studies |
£8,436 | £8,436 |
| The Garve & District Development Company | Woodfuel Business * A decision has been postponed on this. If you are interested please contact the GDCE |
£4,070 | £4,070 |
| The Garve & District Development Company | Community Christmas party | £500 | £500 |
| Garve & District Community Council | Community Ceilidh A community ceilidh in August |
£745 | £745 |
| Garve & District Broadband Group | Satellite ** Installation or reimubursement of satellite broadband to 42 houses. This is a one year solution. |
£22,500 | £22,500 |
| Garve & District Broadband Group | Wireless ** For 3 surveys to be conducted for wireless broadband |
£10,200 | £10,200 |
| Garve and District Development Company | Set up costs for Development Company This was for the administration costs of establishing the development company. LCT will remain separate from the development company |
£250 | £250 |
* these initiatives have been supported as they were high within the community needs survey
** these initiatives have been supported as they were the highest priority on the community needs survey. Although some of Garve has been upgraded to fibre broadband this is not across all of the community and the satellite and wireless broadband solutions offer an option for better broadband
Rejected grants
| Applicant | Project | Grant Requested | Grant Approved |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glenwyvis Distillery | Dingwall Visitor Centre To establish a visitor centre in Dingwall. Rejected as it is outwith and of no benefit to the GDCC area |
£9,235 | £0 |
| Strathconon Primary School | Trips and extra curricular activities Rejected as no children from the GDCC area attend the school |
£3,000 | £0 |
Update on CorrieMoillie wind farm funds
Foundation Scotland has completed a review of Lochluichart Community Trust on behalf of EDF. At a meeting on 17th May all parties had the opportunity to review and comment on the recommendations, following which a summary report has now been created. EDF’s preferred route for funding is to channel it though LCT but there needs to be some changes to enable this as detailed below.
Legal and Governance
- LCT was established following the signing of the Community Benefit Agreement by LLP, Eneco and Highland council.
- This agreement has some clauses which need to be altered including the ability to pay to individuals and the 4% administration cost cap.
- EDF has been in contact with all parties and are currently seeking further legal advice on this. All parties are demonstrating willingness to change the agreement as necessary.
- The Articles of Association may also need to be altered
Adminstration
Many of the recommendations by FS have been implemented including the following:
- Review of the scoring matrix and banding
- Project feedback monitoring form
- Awards to be prioritised according to feedback from the community needs survey. The scoring process has been amended to reflect this
- Support to be provided to applicants during the application process
- Acceptance / rejection letters to be sent by Company Secretary
- Distinguish between different levels of awards. This is achieved by the percentage required being larger for larger projects
- Promotion of LCT through community website, social media etc
The following are to be actioned:
- Director review programme including an induction programme, a Board code of conduct and a skills matrix of all directors
- Multi year grants
- To discuss with GDCC the potential for formal representation of LCT at CC meetings
- Development and strategy day for the Board, to be run every 3 years
The following recommendations were rejected:
- 20% of funds to be earmarked for projects outwith the area
- FS to review the grant funding applications and make recommendations to the Board. It was felt that the community is better served with local directors reviewing and awarding the grants
- Provide latest award reports to GDCC following each award making round. It was felt that LCT and GDCC should remain as 2 distinct organisations and the information is available on the community website if required
- The template grant funding application provided by FS was rejected as it was felt that this was a large cumbersome document and moved away from the requirements that had previously been raised by members for simplicity.
- Discontinue the process of a scoring matrix for the review of grant funding applications
- Seek a minimum for impact figure from applicants. This was rejected as it was felt that this would put off applicants or applicants would assume that they would only get this figure
- Director’s assessment of an application will not be considered if they can’t attend.
- Paying grants electronically. This is not necessary due to the limited amounts of payment
Questions and comments from the community
- Would LCT be spending less money on surveys with the establishment of the development company
-
A concern was raised that there has been money spent on feasibility surveys which have not produced a positive result. Whilst it was agreed by LCT and other members present that there has been funds spent these have been necessary as many community groups would not be able to fund it themselves and expert advice is required. It is also envisaged that once the development company is established it will be able to obtain other options of funding. However, LCT is aware of the concern and has made it a condition of a recent grant that if the feasibility study does not produce a positive result no further funding for feasibility studies will be made available.
- A level of caution needs to be adopted with ongoing changes (ie to application) and members should be consulted
-
A concern was raised that if processes are continually changed this could alter the decision regarding the funding of an application. A suggestion was made that these decisions should be put to members but it was generally agreed that the LCT directors are elected by the members to make decisions.
JGB also commented that whilst it would be good to gain greater community involvement there is a general level of apathy in the community demonstrated in the numbers that have put themselves forward as members of the development company. LCT now has a facebook page, website and community meetings but cannot force members of the community to engage. It is hoped that with the establishment of the development company a full time development officer will be recruited and they will be able to engage with the community and turn ideas into action
- There should be more community involvement with decision making in relation to EDF funds
-
SW explained that EDF have held a number of community consultation meetings and commissioned FS to review LCT processes and as part of this have interviewed past and present directors and applicants. SW explained that following the draft publication of a 47 page report a meeting was held on 17th May between EDF, Foundation Scotland and LCT to discuss the initial findings of the FS review of LCT. There were a number of recommendations (as detailed above) that LCT rejected, in line with previous comments and suggestions from LCT members (ie – FS recommended 20% of the funds should be ringfenced for projects outwith the LCT area. This was rejected by LCT as members had stated at previous community meetings that the funds should remain within the area.) Following the meeting a summary document has been produced by FS and this will now be published to all members of the GDCC area. The summary document has been made available to members at the earliest possible opportunity following the detailed and comprehensive review involving EDF, FS and the LCT directors. Members are welcome to comment on the document or to seek clarification via the LCT Company Secretary.
- Larger scale project applicants would benefit from meeting with directors to discuss the application and not have the application reviewed just on the application form
-
LCT has already engaged with some groups (ie Broadband group) but will enable scope for conversations outside the application form with large value applications. It was also suggested that an exec summary of key points should be provided for large scale projects and this will be checked as part of the pre application check conducted by the Company Secretary.
Following the public meeting, the board has received a request for a meeting with GDCE to clarify elements of their original application and discuss the delivery and impact of the project as a whole going forward. The date is being arranged
- Have the £5,000 funds from Green Highland Renewables for the Luyb Hydro been claimed
-
This has not been claimed but will be chased up
- LCT and the development company
-
It was suggested that, as there have been so few applications to be a member of the development company, there may be some confusion as to whether residents are able to be members of the development company and LCT. CS offered to send out the development company information and application form to LCT members. It was also suggested that GDCC may need to create a flyer to explain the role of the development company.
There was also a discussion as to the interaction between LCT, the development company and the wider community. It was recommended that there should be representatives from all of the community groups as part of the development company.
The meeting was followed by a brief informal update from the Broadband Working Group.