Notes from the community meeting held on 6th February 2017
Members and non-members were invited to the meeting to share their comments and suggestions on LCT. Invitations had been sent to all members by either email or post and posters had been placed up at Garve Hall, Post Office and Achnasheen in order that non-members were also aware of the meeting. Information was also placed on the LCT website and Facebook page.
Present: 14 LCT members
LCT Board: Sharon Wright, Jean Bailey, John Bedwell, Jeanette Fenwick, Karen Grant, David Raeburn, Carol Smith (LCT Company Secretary)
Apologies: Jennifer Haslam
Sharon Wright introduced all of the directors, welcomed everybody and thanked them for coming. The attendees were informed of the key updates since the last community meeting being.
- Draft minutes of the Board meeting are posted on the website “Minutes” page, and emailed or posted to all members. Final minutes are available on the website
- The Facebook page is being used to update members with information and grant requests. This is also being used by members to communicate with LCT. To become a Facebook member you just need to send a request and provided you are a member of LCT it will be accepted
- A summary of the grant funding applications are posted on the website “Outstanding and Previous Applications” page and also on the Facebook page previous to the grant funding application. Please note that LCT will not comment on grant awards previous to the Board reviewing them and making a grant award
- The revised scoring matrix, which was presented to members at the AGM in July 2016 has been used by the Board for 2 rounds of applications, being September and December 2016. This is currently under further review by the directors. Please note that the final grant award decision remains with the directors, as stated in the Grant Funding Application Guidance notes
- The frequency of application has been changed to quarterly with application deadlines being 31 March, 30 June, 30 September and 31 December. Notification of the submission deadlines is on the website
- The LCT Company Secretary has provided support to applicants to ensure all the correct information is obtained to support the application. The most recent example of this is the support given to Strathgarve Parent Council.
- As part of the process for the allocation of the fund from EDF for the Corriemoillie Windfarm, LCT has met with Foundation Scotland who is conducting a review on behalf of EDF. It is anticipated that the report will be available and presented to the community in March 2017
- Project feedback is requested from successful applicants 6 months after their award and this is posted on the website
- Clarification has been sought from Alpin Stewart of George Street Law as to the definition of an initiative. Under section 1.2 and 1.3 of the Highland Council agreement it stated that the objective of LCT is to provide financial support for groups or initiatives that are of benefit to the Garve Area.
- Applications will not be reviewed until all necessary supporting paperwork is received by the Company Secretary. The application must be received by the Company Secretary at the closing dates. This will be reviewed to ensure completeness before being sent to directors review within 7 days of the closing date for applications. Directors will then review the application and respond with any questions or clarification within 7 days. The Company Secretary will contact the applicants with the outstanding requirements. The award decision will not be made by the Directors until all information and clarification has been satisfactorily received. The board will review the application at the board meeting following this.
There was agreement from the attendees present that the Board had covered the points that had been previously raised and implemented actions.
Questions and comments from the community
- Initiatives
-
Having been provided with clarification from Alpin Stewart regarding the definition of an initiative CS also explained that whilst an individual could raise an initiative on behalf of the community the recommendation is that there was a formal group for the initiative. It was also reiterated that the Company Secretary is able to help potential applicants with the application process.
- Has the LCT Board has been in discussion with GDCC regarding the establishment of a development company?
-
SW explained that LCT had provided funds for the community needs survey but the Board felt it was more appropriate to stand back from the process and that LCT needs to be seen as a separate entity with separate membership.
Whilst acknowledging the independence of LCT, there was a further discussion amongst the attendees regarding the setting up of the development company.
- What percentage is required on the scoring matrix to obtain funding for a project?
-
The percentage required depends on the value of the project. However, the % required is currently under review
- How did Dingwall academy get funding for the Rock Challenge?
-
Funding was provided as it fulfilled the criteria required by LCT. At the time of the application LCT confirmed with Dingwall academy that there are children from the GDCC area who are involved with the project.
- Has the criteria changed and applicants do not now need to be constituted?
-
All previous applicants have been constituted but as clarification had now been sought from Alpin Stewart this does not need to be the case, though it is still advisable
- Is it advisable for the EDF funds to go to LCT?
-
This is being reviewed independently by Foundation Scotland on behalf of EDF. The Articles of Association may need to be altered to reflect 2 funding streams and this is not an unusual practice
- Will a development company have to meet the same criteria as any other applicant?
-
The development company will have to meet the same criteria but will be able to spearhead projects on behalf of the community. For example the development company could operate an energy saving initiative and receive the funds for this from LCT and redistribute it to the community. The development company will face the same restrictions on projects as other applicants.
- Education and training grants
-
Sue Tarr explained that she is part of the steering group that has been established by EDF with representatives from each of the CC areas.
- Why do Eneco wish to remove an appointed director?
-
Eneco are considering this as they feel that LCT is operating in the manner expected of it as per the Community agreement.
The meeting was followed by a presentation by the Broadband Working Group.